Bright condominium bedroom with ivory bedding, a blue throw, and a small balcony screened by greenery in Laguna Niguel.

What a Bedroom Is Worth at Crystal Cay in Laguna Niguel

On November 2, the condo at 137 Pearl closed for $479,900. It is an end unit with no neighbor above or below, two levels, a vaulted loft bedroom, a remodeled kitchen and new PEX plumbing installed in 2024. It has one bedroom and 899 square feet, and it took 82 days to sell after starting at $519,900.

In the same 12 months, a two-bedroom unit at 1 Martinique Street with 816 square feet closed for $575,000. It had 83 fewer square feet than 137 Pearl and sold for $95,100 more. The difference was the second bedroom.

That pattern explains most of what is happening in this 303-unit community in Laguna Heights, including a 2026 median that fell much further than the prices of comparable units.

Two bedroom counts, two price bands

Crystal Cay dates to 1983. Shea Homes recorded its tract map that August, and the community fills 18 level acres along Pearl, Grenada, Largo, Martinique and Aruba, near the Laguna Heights Marketplace. Nearly all the homes are condominiums with one or two bedrooms. Among homes sold since 2012 or listed now, the middle half run from 876 to 950 square feet. The streets are private but the community is not gated. It has two pools, spas and volleyball courts.

With floor plans that close in size, you might expect price to follow square footage. In MLS records for closings over the 12 months to mid-November 2026, price follows bedroom count instead.

Address Bedrooms Sq ft Price Per sq ft Closed
1 Largo Street 1 776 $455,000 $586 Jul 17, 2026
55 Martinique 1 791 $480,000 $607 Aug 19, 2026
137 Pearl 1 899 $479,900 $534 Nov 2, 2026
1 Martinique Street 2 816 $575,000 $705 Past 12 months
44 Aruba 2 873 $550,000 $630 Past 12 months
6 Aruba 2 915 $587,950 $643 Aug 20, 2026
75 Grenada Street 2 957 $620,000 $648 Apr 30, 2026
121 Grenada 2 1,096 $599,000 $547 Sep 22, 2026

The one-bedroom closings in this group fall between $455,000 and $480,000, and the two-bedroom closings between $550,000 and $620,000. The lowest two-bedroom sale came in $70,000 above the highest one-bedroom sale. Square footage inside each band barely moves the price. The 1,096-square-foot two-bedroom at 121 Grenada sold for $24,000 less than the 816-square-foot two-bedroom at 1 Martinique Street, and it still went at asking after four days on the market. Among the one-bedrooms, the 899-square-foot unit at 137 Pearl sold for $100 less than the 791-square-foot unit at 55 Martinique.

Why the 2026 median fell by $107,000

Crystal Cay's median sale price was $607,000 across six sales in 2025. For 2026, through November 15, it is $500,000 across nine sales. Read as a price trend, that is a 17.6 percent decline in one year.

The median price per square foot moved the other way over the same periods, from $622 in 2025 to $643 in 2026 to date. A median of $500,000 means at least half of this year's closings landed at or below $500,000, which is where one-bedrooms sell. Last year's $607,000 median sits among the two-bedroom prices. With only six to nine sales a year, a few more one-bedroom closings are enough to pull the median down by most of a bedroom's worth of price, while small two-bedrooms like 1 Martinique Street, at $705 a square foot, push the per-square-foot figure up.

Prices within each band have eased too, but by much less than $107,000. One-bedrooms closed at $525,000 in July 2025 and $475,000 in November 2025, against $455,000 to $480,000 in 2026. Two-bedrooms closed between $585,000 and $629,000 in spring 2025, plus $650,000 and $680,000 for the two largest plans, against $550,000 to $620,000 over the past 12 months. That is a softening of tens of thousands of dollars within each band. The mix of units sold accounts for the rest of the drop in the median.

Over the longer run, median price per square foot in Crystal Cay rose from $199 in 2012 to $488 in 2021, then to $589 in 2022 and $667 in 2024. It has stayed in the low-to-mid $600s since then. The steep climb ended around 2022. Sales volume has also thinned. Crystal Cay recorded 26 sales in 2021 and 23 in 2020, and since 2022 annual sales have run between 6 and 12. With so few sales each year, a handful of closings can move the median a long way.

What extra square footage buys at the one-bedroom price

Because buyers here pay by bedroom, the larger one-bedroom plans sell for close to what the smaller ones do. 137 Pearl closed at $534 a square foot, the lowest figure in the table, for a unit with two levels, a loft bedroom with a built-in desk and a walk-in closet, and an end-unit position near the pool and spa.

For a buyer who works from home or wants space more than a second bedroom, that $534 is a better measure of value than the community median of $645 a square foot for the 12 months ending November 9, 2026.

For a seller, the same unit points the other way. A larger one-bedroom is priced against the other one-bedrooms, not against two-bedroom units of similar size. 137 Pearl started at $519,900, above every one-bedroom closing in the table, and needed 82 days and a reduction to sell. Over the past three years, the median Crystal Cay sale went under contract in 17 days at 99.8 percent of its final list price.

This fall's closings had one more thing in common. 137 Pearl, 6 Aruba and 121 Grenada all sold to cash buyers. A financed offer at this price point competes against those buyers, and its terms carry as much weight as its price.

The same monthly dues on either side of the gap

The purchase price follows bedroom count. The dues, as recorded in MLS data, do not. Recent listings show Crystal Cay association dues of $540 a month, and some records add a separate $122 monthly assessment from the Laguna Heights master association, for a combined $662. The 137 Pearl listing showed both figures. Its remarks describe two heated pools, two spas, a dog park, walking trails, maintained landscaping, guest parking and trash service as community amenities.

Dues that stay about the same across both bands make a larger share of a one-bedroom's monthly cost. Our mortgage calculator lets you add the dues to a one-bedroom and a two-bedroom scenario side by side. These dues figures come from MLS records for individual units as of fall 2026, so confirm the current amount for any specific unit with the association. This is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and your own situation is best reviewed with the appropriate professional.

The Crystal Cay Homeowners Association runs an owner portal for announcements and documents. Its FAQ sends leasing applications through Affinity's management portal and lists [email protected] as the contact address.

Where this fall's two-bedroom listings sit

The two-bedroom asking prices in mid-November are where the bands look most likely to move. 82 Largo, a 950-square-foot two-bedroom built in 1984, came on the market October 30 at $599,000 and was reduced by $50,000 to $549,000 on November 11. In the same mid-November snapshot, other active two-bedrooms were asking $555,000 for 873 square feet at 85 Pearl, $529,900 for 868 square feet at 73 Martinique, $538,000 for 1,018 square feet at 87 Pearl and $559,000 for 915 square feet at 15 Aruba. 22 Aruba, a 915-square-foot two-bedroom asking $539,000, was under contract. A 715-square-foot one-bedroom at 65 Largo Street was asking $478,700.

Every one of those two-bedroom asking prices sits between $529,900 and $559,000, at or near the bottom of the $550,000 to $620,000 range where two-bedrooms closed over the past 12 months. The one-bedroom asking price matches its band. If the two-bedroom listings close near those figures, the gap between one and two bedrooms narrows from about $70,000 toward $50,000. Listing status changes quickly at this time of year, so check the current price and status before you plan a showing.

If the larger homes nearby are on your list, Niguel Pointe gives a useful comparison. It was first built in 1986, with condos and twin homes of two to four bedrooms and 1,220 to 1,738 square feet. A 1,513-square-foot Niguel Pointe home sold in October 2026 for $1,065,000. Crystal Cay is the entry point to Laguna Heights ownership, and the jump to the next tier is large. More on the surrounding neighborhoods is in our Laguna Niguel guide.

If you own a Crystal Cay unit, the first number to know is your bedroom band, ahead of price per square foot or the community median. Judy Parsons can walk you through the closings that match your floor plan, and her concierge program lets sellers fund pre-listing improvements and pay for them at closing. Book a complimentary home strategy session, or start with a home valuation that compares your unit with Crystal Cay sales of the same bedroom count.

Work With Judy

Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.

FOLLOW ME